India’s Supreme Court has paused the implementation of three controversial new agricultural laws.
Farmers have been blocking roads and protesting around the capital since November.
They say the new laws will undercut prices and allow a few corporates to control the agricultural sector.
According to local reports, judges are disappointed with the government’s handling of the weeks-long standoff and fear it could lead to bloodshed.
Al Jazeera’s Elizabeth Puranam joins us from the Ghazipur border crossing to discuss the latest updates.
– Subscribe to our channel: http://aje.io/AJSubscribe
– Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AJEnglish
– Find us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aljazeera
– Check our website: https://www.aljazeera.com/
#India #IndiaFarmersProtest #IndiaSupremeCourt
1. The three farm bills are already in place and working fine as of now
and they are part of congress , bjp, ncf parties 2019 election manifesto.
ex farmer minister of ncp and present congress chief minister of punjab also
supported the same reforms in the past. Now all oppositon parties change their stand and making farmers scape goat.
2. post dialogue with farmers and govt ,On december 9th clarified with 10 point
amendment
that all the doubts farmers posed and will be tabled in next session of
parliament. But protesting farmers unions change stand after dec 9th
and want full repeal.
3. In 2019 farmers can't sell their
produced rice/wheat/vegetables etc out side of the district or county
and cant sell to any one outside of the APMC market yards/mandis and
farmer has to pay 8.5 percent fees( 3% to market yard improvement, 3% to
district development , 2.5% to licensed commision agents). In some
markets they collect both from seller and buyer each 8.5% . These new
2020 farm laws allows farmers to sell to any where in india to any one .
no restriction. It is upto local government to charge needed cess or
fees.
4. In 2019 only 10% of total agriculture produce (mainly
wheat and rice)was bought by government agency FCI (Food Corporation of
India as a stockpile for emergeny security) . 85% was purchased by
private buyers . In 2019 only 15% of produce of total agriculture was
purchased at minimum support price (MSP) and rest was purchased at lower
price. Till 2010 the minimum support price was lower than the
international price of the goods. After 2010 the minimum support price
was increased higher than international price and no exporter is
buying at msp except govt agency and all godowns of FCI agency are full with 4.5 trillion tonnes of wheat and rice .
5. who is at loss due to this farm bills of 2020 are
A. punjab state governments who charge 3% cess for district
developement will loose around 15000 millions (1500 crores) indian
rupees per year income.
B. the punjab licensed commision agents (who are mainly punjabi sikh jat caste landlords )who get 2.5%
charge per transaction thro markets will loose 1000 crores (10000
million) rupees per year only in punjab state.
c. Other than punjab and haryana no other state charge district fees and market cess
and they charge only commision agent fees. Some states there are no
markets/mandis like in kerala (since 1980) and bihar (since 2008).
6. The funding for protest is happening by charging 500 rupees per farmer .
80% farmers own only less than 2 hectres /5 acre land.
7. The foreign punjab seperatist/secissionist group sikh for justice announced 1
millon dollars as donation and indian banks stoped the
distribution asking account holder to show FCRA ( Foreign control regulatory) registrants for permission
8. All want farm reforms. Punjab and Haryana farmers unions want to repeal
and rest of indian country farmers are happy that they can sell
anywhere. I think if central/union govt gives that 1500 crores to punjab
govt per year and 1000 crore to punjab commision agents it will stop.
Supreme Court ko chahie ki agar aurat aurat ki had Mein rahti hai tu hi vah hote hain Varna Aurat ke andar hajaron Charitra Hote Hain aur Supreme Court an hajaron Charitra ko bhul Kar Kisi bhi Aurat ke sath Kyon hamdardi jata hai kya hua yah Jaanta hai kya hua Ek Aurat Hain yah UN hajaron Chitron Mein uska koi Charitra hai Sabse pahle A Supreme Court ko chahie Kevat ka chete nirdharit Karen Uske bad Uske bare Mein Kuchh Faisla Le Ja Uske dwara Lagaye Kisi vyakti per Kisi dost ka Saja sunayen ya nahin sabse pahle aur Aurat ko aurat ki paribhasha Shikayat ke Aurat kya hoti hai Varna aur uske andar samajshastra batate Hain Ki hajaron Teri Tarah hote hain randi Aur vyaktiyon Ke Andar bhi randi Rand banaa Jo Karte lekin vah aurat ka Roop hota hai aur 15000 rupay Gari Charitra hote hain lekin aurat ka Charitra Charitra hota hai jo Jivani ko acche ghar grihasti ko Naman Karta Hai Varna Aurat aurat ka jo jo Stri roop hai na Aur Ka it rup Hai Uske alava Anya Sabhi Uske Roop dekar Hain vah samaj mein gandgi Pal Aane Wale Hain is tarika Aurat rupee hai jo ghar grihasti chalane wala hai
Supreme Court ko chahie Ki Aurat Aur Ti Rahe Shubhra Aurat ko aur tab tak Rahega Gaye Dekhte Nahin deta Jo unko Raja Ji Neta Agarwal aur Azadi Mein Jayegi tu aur Tumhare payegi
Supreme Court Agar auraton ke upar nyaay Jari Karti Hai To vah aurat ki Seema bhi nirdharit Karen ki ya Aurat Aurat hai aur yah aurat aur Nahin Hua randi Chandal Chandal pata nahin kya kya kya karte hain aur sath mein hajaron teri Tarah hote hain to auraton ka Charitra shareit Karen aur Aurat hone ke Chitra per usko aurat ki upadhi dijiye Varna auraten aaj ke time ki jarurat hai na yah 2021 chal chuka hai is time Ki Jo auraten auraten Nahin vahan Chandal ne apne Insan ko khane wali Hain sabse pahle Agar Supreme Court ka chahie to aurat ki Seema nirdharit Karen kya hua apne aap mein baat Kahi Mein Ek Aurat Hai yah randi Hai yah Veshya hai ya nahin hai kya hai uske bad Mein Supreme Court Ka Adhikar Hai Ki vah Kisi Ke Upar Bhi Koi Kanoon Banaya Yana banae
Agar koi aur to Aurat ke naam ka sirf Sahara Lekar aurat ka koi bhi father niwai To Kya Hua aur kahan Jaega kya Supreme Court sewada Rajendra Kumar ka
Supreme Court hai koi bhi photo aur Jaat ki paribhasha Aati Hai Aurat ke andar hajaron Charitra hote hain agar koi Aurat ko Aurat Aurat hai aur uske sath Koi Jagah ho raha hun Koi Anya ho raha hai to man liya lekin randi ke sath Anyay ho raha hai randi gand Marati FIR rahi hai to uska kya hua hai kya usko aur to Manoj vyavastha Manoj aap Agar Ek vyakti Hai To Kya Scott Mana jaega
Agar koi Aurat Aurat ke Naam Ka Sahara Lekar aur randi aur kuchh Jyada Jaise aur kam karen to kya usko Aurat kahan jaega
Why should supreme court take up all cases involving executive actions? Better confine to constitutional issues.
Mississipii( alabama like charge a twin state like )
Modi stupid pm of India
The Partition of India & Punjab was not accepted by the Panjabi community mainly Sikh as large parts of Punjab given to Pakistan moreover most of Sikh holy site were found in the Pakistani side of Punjab..
Infact founder of Sikh, Sri Gurunak Saheb was born in Pakistani side of Panjab
In 1966 sardar were on the street against CM Bhargawa for seprate nation or atleast separate Punjabi state with exclusively for Sikh people.
Not only that they said we only want Sikh CM in Punjab otherwise we will riot..
Again this is exactly what started to happened all the non Sikh either kicked out or killed or converted into Sikh and since then the CM of Punjab were only a Sikh…
As per Khalistani movement, state of Haryana and Himachal Pradesh will be merge with Punjab and country will be called Khalistan and amtrisar capital
Supreme court is working under bjp government
what kind of farm law if you don't even know farmers's pain points nor ask farmers for their voices?? Only secretly pass this BS while whole india was in lockdown
Go Indian farmers! The world is with you!
This is ruining the farmers livelihood…
go protest for farmers' right!
These farmers have every right to protest they’ve been commiting suicide due to laws that don’t protect them
Indian supreme court is on the Oligarh payroll
so-called protest lol
__ On what basis has supreme court stayed new farm laws?
____What is wrong with new farm laws?
_ When will supreme court order farmers to vacate blocked roads?
There are plenty of committe reports recommending new farm laws. Its been happening from past 20 to 25 years.
__ What was the need for this new committe?
All farmers groups have said, they reject supreme court intervention.
__ What is the use of judgement, when it will be rejected?
The greatest tragedy is, courts are always correct/great/unquestionable/ultimate.
__ Why don't any one question courts?
It's all same clerical work running round and round repeatedly indefinitely. Exactly like court procedures/ adjournments.
It says, it does not want blood.
Supreme court is heavely influenced by mobsters, rioters, criminals. It's not a fearless independent order.